HOW TO PROVE INCAPACITY for work
"You've proved your injury, so you automatically get income compensation, right? Wrong. Proving your incapacity for work so that you are entitled to income compensation is an ongoing process."
What is incapacity for work?
Incapacity for work is the worker's loss in earning power. Some injuries do not result in loss of earning power. Sometimes an injury moves the worker to another occupation, which results in equal or greater earning power.
Most times, an injury does result in a loss of earning power. Disputes arise when a worker regains some earning power, but the worker has problems finding a job. The worker, in theory has labour to sell, but no employer wants to buy it because they are turned off by the worker's medical restrictions.
A worker will always get the best result they could have got from the workers' compensation system if they have a good attitude and do their best to return to some kind of work.
Unfortunately, some workers do fall through the cracks in the workers' compensation system. Harry Evans will do his best to make sure that doesn't happen to you.
Section 48 and Section 50
Section 48 of the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 2023 provides the following:
48 . Total or partial incapacity for work
(1) For any period during which a worker is totally incapacitated for work, the amount of income compensation must be calculated in accordance with Subdivision 3.
(2) For any period during which a worker is partially incapacitated for work, the amount of income compensation is obtained by calculating, in accordance with Subdivision 3, the amount that would apply if the worker were totally incapacitated for work and deducting from it the amount the worker earns, or is able to earn, in suitable employment.
Note for this subsection:
Section 50 provides for an arbitrator to be able, in certain circumstances, to order that a worker who is partially incapacitated for work is taken to be totally incapacitated for work.
(3) A worker is not entitled to any income compensation for a time during which the worker earns, or is able to earn, in suitable employment an amount equal to or greater than the amount of income compensation that would apply if the worker were totally incapacitated for work. Section 50 of the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 2023 provides the following: 50 . Order that worker is taken to be totally incapacitated (1) A worker who has a partial incapacity for work and has been unable to obtain suitable employment may apply for an arbitrator to order that the worker is taken to be totally incapacitated for work.
(2) On application under this section, an arbitrator may order that the worker is taken to be totally incapacitated for work while the order is effective.
(3) The order may specify —
(a) the period for which it is effective; and
(b) conditions that must be satisfied for the order to be effective.
(4) The order must not be made unless the arbitrator is satisfied that —
(a) the worker has taken all reasonable steps to obtain, and has failed to obtain, suitable employment; and
(b) the failure to obtain suitable employment is wholly or mainly a result of the injury.
(2) For any period during which a worker is partially incapacitated for work, the amount of income compensation is obtained by calculating, in accordance with Subdivision 3, the amount that would apply if the worker were totally incapacitated for work and deducting from it the amount the worker earns, or is able to earn, in suitable employment.
Note for this subsection:
Section 50 provides for an arbitrator to be able, in certain circumstances, to order that a worker who is partially incapacitated for work is taken to be totally incapacitated for work.
(3) A worker is not entitled to any income compensation for a time during which the worker earns, or is able to earn, in suitable employment an amount equal to or greater than the amount of income compensation that would apply if the worker were totally incapacitated for work. Section 50 of the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 2023 provides the following: 50 . Order that worker is taken to be totally incapacitated (1) A worker who has a partial incapacity for work and has been unable to obtain suitable employment may apply for an arbitrator to order that the worker is taken to be totally incapacitated for work.
(2) On application under this section, an arbitrator may order that the worker is taken to be totally incapacitated for work while the order is effective.
(3) The order may specify —
(a) the period for which it is effective; and
(b) conditions that must be satisfied for the order to be effective.
(4) The order must not be made unless the arbitrator is satisfied that —
(a) the worker has taken all reasonable steps to obtain, and has failed to obtain, suitable employment; and
(b) the failure to obtain suitable employment is wholly or mainly a result of the injury.
Additional Income Compensation
Section 52 of the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 2023 provides the following:
52 . Additional income compensation
(1) In this section —
former rate means the weekly rate at which a worker’s final payment of income compensation under this Subdivision (other than under this section) is calculated.
(2) A worker may apply for an arbitrator to order that the worker is entitled to additional income compensation for incapacity for work resulting from an injury.
(3) The application may be made only if —
(a) the total of all amounts of income compensation paid for the worker’s incapacity exceeds 75% of the income compensation general limit amount applying when the application is made; and
(b) the employer’s liability for compensation in respect of the injury concerned has not been commuted by a settlement agreement registered under Division 12.
Note for this subsection:
Provisional payments by the employer in respect of income compensation are taken into account for the purposes of this subsection as income compensation paid by the employer — see section 43.
(4) On application under this section, an arbitrator may order that the worker is entitled to additional income compensation if the arbitrator is satisfied that —
(a) the worker’s injury has resulted in the permanent total incapacity of the worker for work; and
(b) the additional income compensation should be allowed, having regard to the social and financial circumstances and the reasonable financial needs of the worker.
(5) The arbitrator must, having regard to the matters referred to in subsection (4)(b), specify in the order the weekly rate at which additional income compensation is to be calculated, being a rate not exceeding the former rate.
(6) The order may specify —
(a) the period for which the worker is entitled to the additional income compensation; or
(b) the maximum total amount of all additional income compensation that may be made for the worker’s incapacity.
(7) The order may, in an appropriate case, require additional income compensation to be paid for the period from the end of the last period in respect of which the worker previously received income compensation to the day on which the order is made, and the order may specify when arrears for that period are to be paid.
(8) The order must not result in the total amount of all additional income compensation that may be paid for the worker’s incapacity being capable of exceeding the lesser of —
(a) the amount that is 75% of the income compensation general limit amount applying on the day on which the order is made; and
(b) the amount calculated by multiplying the former rate by the number of weeks in the period of the expectation of life of the worker as at the commencement of the first period for which additional income compensation is to be paid.
former rate means the weekly rate at which a worker’s final payment of income compensation under this Subdivision (other than under this section) is calculated.
(2) A worker may apply for an arbitrator to order that the worker is entitled to additional income compensation for incapacity for work resulting from an injury.
(3) The application may be made only if —
(a) the total of all amounts of income compensation paid for the worker’s incapacity exceeds 75% of the income compensation general limit amount applying when the application is made; and
(b) the employer’s liability for compensation in respect of the injury concerned has not been commuted by a settlement agreement registered under Division 12.
Note for this subsection:
Provisional payments by the employer in respect of income compensation are taken into account for the purposes of this subsection as income compensation paid by the employer — see section 43.
(4) On application under this section, an arbitrator may order that the worker is entitled to additional income compensation if the arbitrator is satisfied that —
(a) the worker’s injury has resulted in the permanent total incapacity of the worker for work; and
(b) the additional income compensation should be allowed, having regard to the social and financial circumstances and the reasonable financial needs of the worker.
(5) The arbitrator must, having regard to the matters referred to in subsection (4)(b), specify in the order the weekly rate at which additional income compensation is to be calculated, being a rate not exceeding the former rate.
(6) The order may specify —
(a) the period for which the worker is entitled to the additional income compensation; or
(b) the maximum total amount of all additional income compensation that may be made for the worker’s incapacity.
(7) The order may, in an appropriate case, require additional income compensation to be paid for the period from the end of the last period in respect of which the worker previously received income compensation to the day on which the order is made, and the order may specify when arrears for that period are to be paid.
(8) The order must not result in the total amount of all additional income compensation that may be paid for the worker’s incapacity being capable of exceeding the lesser of —
(a) the amount that is 75% of the income compensation general limit amount applying on the day on which the order is made; and
(b) the amount calculated by multiplying the former rate by the number of weeks in the period of the expectation of life of the worker as at the commencement of the first period for which additional income compensation is to be paid.
The Battle of the Experts
- Workers believe that they can rely on their expert report alone to prove their total incapacity for work.
- However, the reality is that when the insurer's expert asserts that the worker has some capacity for work, an arbitrator will not be convinced that the worker has proven they have total incapacity for work, unless the worker is limping around in pain.
- If an arbitrator sees a worker walking around freely without apparent pain or restrictions or constantly drives themselves around, the arbitrator will not be convinced that the worker has total incapacity for work. An arbitrator does not have to accept an expert's conclusions on incapacity when the arbitrator can plainly see evidence of the worker's physical abilities to the contrary.
- Expert reports from the treating GP or a specialist are crucial to proving a worker's case, but they only take a worker so far.
- Experts don't determine incapacity - arbitrators do. The arbitrator does not have to accept the evidence of the worker's expert or the insurer's expert if the underlying facts of the expert's conclusions are not proven in evidence.
- Sometimes an arbitrator won't accept either expert. Whomever is the applicant will have their case dismissed because they have not discharged their burden of proof.
- The best evidence of a worker's incapacity for work is the labour market.
Proving the Negative
- A worker has to prove that there is no suitable employment available to them. This is simpler than you think, but it takes patience and persistence over several months, perhaps even a year. The worker should apply for dozens of jobs to prove that they have made reasonable efforts. The typical occupations that insurers allege that could be suitable employment are:
- Taxi driver (Taxi companies won't employ people who cannot put luggage in the boot or change tyres)
- Courier driver (Courier companies won't employ people who have problems getting in out of a van or problems walking up and down steps and stairs)
- Gate keeper (It is debatable whether this occupation exists in Perth on the open market - it is often given to older security guards - but it easy to prove that this not suitable employment if you cannot perform CPR - which is required to be a security guard)
- CCTV operator (It is debatable whether this occupation exists in Perth on the open market - it is often given to older security guards - but it easy to prove that this not suitable employment if you cannot perform CPR - which is required to be a security guard)
- Weigh bridge operator (It is debatable whether this occupation even exists in Perth)
- Call centre operator (It is debatable whether this occupation even exists in Perth at an entry-level. These employer won't employ people who have problems sitting for long periods of time or have problems operating a keyboard and mouse for long periods of time)
- Service station attendant (Service stations won't employ people who have problems mopping floors, cleaning, and unloading stock)
- Fast food attendant (Fast food restaurants won't employ people who have problems standing for long periods of time and cleaning)
- Meter reader (Gas and power companies won't employ people who cannot walk 10 to 15 km a day or have problems walking up and down steps and stairs)
- Seated electronic assembler (These employers won't employ people who have problems sitting for long periods of time)
- The injured worker should apply for jobs through websites like Seek because those websites keep track of the job applications. It's best not to mention your injury in the job application. The goal of the job application is to get an interview - that proves that the employer believes that you are qualified for the job. Once you attend the interview, then you should mention your injury. This is about safety. The employer needs to know what risks they are taking on and whether they are able to make reasonable adjustments for your medical restrictions. If you have one or two rejections from employers for a particular occupation because of your injury, then that is likely to convince an arbitrator that that particular occupation is not suitable employment for you - that is "proving the negative". Now repeat the same process for all of the other occupations that the insurer alleges that are suitable employment for you.
- If you are applying for a job that requires a pre-employment medical examination, you need to follow through with the examination and be deemed unfit for the job. It is not enough that you decide yourself that you will fail the examination - the doctor has to decide that.
- If the worker has a workplace rehabilitation provider, the worker should also ask them to contact prospective employers and ask them if they would employ the worker with the worker's medical restrictions. If after many enquires, no employer will employ the worker because of their injury, then the worker has proven that they should be taken as totally incapacitated.
- If an employer offers you a job, you are obligated to take it. If the job pays less than your income compensation rate, you will be eligible for a "top-up" payment. If the job pays more, your income compensation payments will come to an end. If you need more help on how to prove that you are unemployable because of your injury, please contact Harry Evans.
Get in Touch
We look forward to hearing from you.
Address
Level 25, 108 St Georges Tce,
PERTH WA 6000